In March 2019, a malicious Twitter user called
, less than 50 followers)
abused the Twitter complaints process
in order to get
Twitter to ban popular right-of-centre Irish commentator
, 12,000 followers).
Twitter is broken.
Twitter's complaints process
is incredibly broken and wide open to this kind of abuse.
And this is a great example.
This page explains what happened.
The troll in question.
It seems unlikely
this is a real name or real photo.
The malicious complaint
Paddy Manning tweeted this harmlessly amusing tweet after an egg was thrown at
the extremist British politician Jeremy Corbyn on 3 March 2019.
He is slagging off the anti-semitic conspiracy theorists
that flock to Corbyn's Labour.
who disagrees with Paddy's politics,
decided to try to get Paddy banned for the above tweet.
So he made a malicious complaint.
Maybe the AI bot or outsourced worker dealing with the complaint could be fooled into thinking Paddy's tweet was anti-semitic,
rather than slagging off anti-semites.
Paddy was banned from Twitter.
See full size.
From Paddy's Facebook.
boasts that it was him who made the malicious complaint.
He is delighted that it worked.
What a feeling of power for someone whose tweets no one wants to read
to silence someone whose tweets thousands of people want to read, but now cannot.
We cannot follow Paddy any more, because we all must obey Finbar Prendergast.
What a rush of power this must be for him.
The troll is having a great time
I don't think Finbar Prendergast is an anti-semite.
I think he just enjoys making malicious complaints and getting people banned.
Twitter needs to fix this.
And remove Finbar Prendergast's account.
It's all a game to the troll. He is having a great time.
Twitter is allowing no-follower trolls like him
to take down popular, highly-followed accounts.
Imagine being a business and allowing drunken non-customers ruin the experience of actual customers.
The troll goes completely mad
In response to this page, this guy has gone completely mad.
The troll targets me
He sends a shooting threat to someone.
He libels me.
He harasses my employer.
"Fuck your mother".
Twitter listens to the pious, pleading (and entirely fake) complaints of trolls like this.
In April 2019, after many complaints about his behaviour, from many people,
the troll prenners was suspended.
But Paddy Manning is still gone.
Twitter is still obeying the troll that they themselves suspended.
The troll returns
- Of course the troll didn't care he was suspended. He just opened a new account and came back as
- He then switched to FinnbarrP.
- If you are anonymous, like the troll, you cannot be banned from Twitter.
- If you give your real name, like Paddy Manning, you can be banned from Twitter.
- Anonymous drunken trolls (who no one follows and who would never pay Twitter anything)
can get real public figures (who thousands follow and who would happily pay a subscription) banned.
- Twitter's business model is a mess.
Twitter is broken.